URL |
Thumb |
The Journal Portal
Browse Journals |
Polls |
deviantART [dee·vee·un'nt·ART]
Keep in Touch!
|
Deviousness |
First, I really enjoyed this work. That might be perhaps, due to the form/rhyming scheme and the meter which is really well handled throughout the work. Thus even if I hadn't understood anything, I would have accepted this as an enjoyable read.
Now moving on. The second line of the first stanza does not require the "a" before deafening. I think the expression is fine without it in both terms of meaning and meter. But it is not that big of a problem.
The first stanza starts with a very different feel. It pulls the reader in and makes them wonder what the rest of the work may be about.
The second stanza gives some insight over the different possibilities the first stanza gave and the expressions used here are wonderful. Note that the first stanza, though it holds the same form as the rest, seems like it work follows aaaa scheme while it actually follows abba. Not a technical problem again but I was a bit... uncertain when I read the second stanza. Anyways, the second stanza is very well worded.
The third stanza... and fourth stanza... nothing wrong, well written and good. Now coming to what I inferred from this work.
It felt in the first stanza that you are regretting or perhaps painfully contemplating on an issue. What it is, is hinted in the second stanza. It is of perhaps a romantic endeavor. You feel escalated and as if you have everything you could ever desire. The third stanza then brings you back to reality. It shows you that this was not a... correct choice perhaps, or not the right thing to do. I do not understand the expression and its implication: "turning their hearts into ice" and the sudden addition of dolls to the work, with no previous reference to them suddenly put me in a strange position. Anyways, then the last stanza gives the impression that you are just thinking over what happened in an hour, hearing nothing, saying nothing, just wondering how just an hour of "pleasure" brought this eternity of regret.
This is what I understood and it might completely mismatch what you intended. So the theme is there, it is well written, but there is a strange moment in the third stanza. I don't know if you plan on editing it but an addition of a stanza might help, since I feel the rest of the stanza's work fine as they are. OR you may edit this stanza and make it clear.
Over all a wonderful piece which I really enjoyed!
I really appreciate it ^_^
Constructive critiques are quite rare nowadays and I always try to learn from them. Especially because english is not my native language and I am quite prone to making grammar mistakes
I'll definitely take your suggestions into account.
Thanks again
Prettyflour here on behalf of
I find this poem very interesting for several reasons. First, I'm not exactly sure what it is about, and I like the fact that it is somewhat vague and open to interpretation. It forces the reader to think and contemplate. It is not about instant gratification. That is my kind of poem! Secondly, I like the way you structured this and used rhyme. I find it quite original and refreshing.
The repitition of the first and last line works very well. I like that you changed it up a bit in the last line- that slight change gave the ending a sense of finality and made the poem seem complete. I did have a question about your use of an apostrophe in eternity's. Is this short for eternity is? Or was this meant to show eternity as its own being? Or eternty in plural? I have to admit... I was a little thrown off by this because I'm not quite sure of your intention.
One the whole, I think this has a nice flow and it was easy to read but with a lot of meaning meaning the words. I very much enjoyed this! I hope this was helpful and if you'd like to discuss, pelase feel free to reply.
Thanks and have a great day!
Thanks a lot for the comment and fave ^_^
Stepping away from my traditional form of critiquing, I will simply say outright... I fell in love with this piece. There is nothing for me to critique. Honestly. Your use of power words and metaphors.... gave me shivers. The subject matter was incredibly intense. I would point out which parts I loved, but that would require me to place the entire poem into quotations! Absolutely fantastic job!
I appreciate it very much